July 2025

02/07/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Flux calibration: For the physics in astrophysics shouldn't we use SI-units (and why SI and not IS)
Amelia María Bayo Aran (ESO)

Abstract

With the simple mind of a mathematician, I almost ran away from the lab when I started coding my SED fitter and encountered the "beautiful mess" of: magnitudes, photometric systems and filters (exact same name for two filters with remarkably different transmission curves), photon vs energy counting, etc. And even when finally the fluxes were in physical units... here comes the debate on what is the suitable lambda to use (for plotting!! :-)) and the strong opinions regarding fluxes and
density fluxes... Little did I understand at that point that it is not that astrophysicist like to complicate their lives (don't we?), but that there is a fascinating combination of historical and technical reasons that prevent having a "clean" and homogeneous way to go from what is observable to SI traceable flux measurements. In this ID I will go
briefly on how we calibrate now, why it is not enough for some cases and interesting initiatives in this context like the Landolt Satellite Project.

June 2025

25/06/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Don't forget about the ionized-gas: free-free and recombination line "contamination" in millimeter-wavelength observations of star formation.
Roberto Galván Madrid (IRyA, UNAM)
18/06/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Isotopic ratios paradox: a deep study of M1-92
Elisa Mas (Observatorio Astronómico Nacional)

Abstract

The shaping of planetary nebulae on their evolution from asymptotic giant branch (AGB) circumstellar envelopes (CSE)

to their final, most often axisymmetrical, form is still a process with many unknown details. For this, the study of the transition

objects, pre-planetary nebulae (pPNe), is key to understand the whole shaping process. After creating a detailed 3-D

morpho-kinematical model of M1–92, a pPN with one of the richest chemistry, we obtain a full description of the nebula’s

physical and chemical properties, finding robust discrepancies in the 12C/13C isotopic ratio across structures depending on

their age and linking it to its ongoing shaping process.

04/06/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — 2025 Gruber Prize for Cosmology
Celine Peroux (ESO)

May 2025

28/05/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — A new instrument for conducting ultra broad band (U to K) spectroscopy survey of young stellar objects
Joe Ninan (Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai)

Abstract

Multi epoch spectroscopy still remains our only probe to understand the innermost (< 1AU) regions of protoplanetary discs. We have a long-running program for monitoring FUors and EXors to understand the accretion and outflow phenomenon in YSOs. With this motivation, I shall talk about our new project to build a novel spectrograph, which will be the fastest spectrograph for ultra broad band spectroscopy survey in the world. This instrument, dubbed TA-MOONS will be a next generation instrument on the 3.6 m DOT, India, that will have the unique capability to observe up to 8 targets anywhere in the 12 arc min diameter field of view in the ultra broad band wavelength range of 370 nm to 2.5 micron simultaneously.
I look forward to a discussion on both the science and instrumentation aspect.
21/05/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Discussion on reference letters: summary on the report of the AAS Graduate Admissions Task Force
Anna Francesca Pala (ESO)

Abstract

The number of applications to graduate programs is growing extremely fast without a significant increase in the number of available positions, making it harder to run an admissions process that is fair and efficient. Last week, the AAS Graduate Admissions Task Force (GATF) released a summary of their final report, which includes recommendations aimed at improving the current state of graduate admissions in astronomy. One of the topics they addressed is the use of recommendation letters, which were also the focus of a recent open letter from early-career researchers to the GATF. In this ID, I’ll summarise the key points from both documents, focusing on the role of recommendation letters, with the aim to discuss together whether, in their current form, they are truly effective tools for evaluating students fairly and equitably.

07/05/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — She Figures 2024
Francesca Primas (ESO, Garching)

April 2025

16/04/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Sources of EoR and their impacts on IGM (thesis defense practice)
Arghyadeep Basu (MPA)

Abstract

The Epoch of Reionization (EoR) marks a critical phase in the evolution of the universe, yet remains poorly understood. While star-forming galaxies are acknowledged as key contributors to ionized bubble formation, the extent of contribution from alternative sources such as shock-heated ISM or emission from X-ray binaries remains unclear. In this study, we employ cosmological radiative transfer simulations to explore the impact of diverse sources on intergalactic medium (IGM) properties. Our focus is not merely data fitting, but rather understanding whether the interpretation of Lyman-ɑ forest observations is changed by using theoretical models incorporating non-stellar sources.

 

Moving beyond the EoR, the study explores the Epoch of Helium Reionization (HeEoR), when HeII transitions to HeIII (𝑧 ≲ 4), predominantly driven by quasar-produced ionizing photons. Using the parametrization of the quasar luminosity function (QLF) proposed by Shen et al. (2020), we examine its implications for recent observations suggesting an extended HeEoR.

 

Finally, the study delves into the origin of UV luminosity function (UVLF) variability, potentially explaining the unexpectedly high abundance of UV-bright galaxies at extreme redshifts observed by JWST. By exploring the stochasticity of star formation and dust attenuation driven by different implementations of supernova feedback, we provide insights into the UVLF's evolution and its link to early galaxy morphologies. This presentation will highlight these findings and their broader implications for our understanding of cosmic reionization.

02/04/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Hyper-runaway and hypervelocity white dwarf candidates in Gaia DR3
Andrei Igoshev (Royal Society University Research Fellow at Newcastle University)

Abstract

Type Ia and other peculiar supernovae (SNe) are thought to originate from the thermonuclear explosions of white dwarfs (WDs). Some of the proposed channels involve the ejection of a partly exploded WD (e.g. Iax SN remnant) or the companion of an exploding WD at extremely high velocities (>400 km s-1). Characterization of such hyper-runaway/hypervelocity (HVS) WDs might therefore shed light on the physics and origins of SNe. Here we analyse the Gaia DR3 data to search for HVS WDs candidates and peculiar sub-main-sequence (sub-MS) objects. We retrieve the previously identified HVSs and find 46 new HVS candidates. Among these we identify two new unbound WDs and two new unbound sub-MS candidates. The remaining stars are hyper-runaway WDs and hyper-runaway sub-MS stars. The numbers and properties of the HVS WD and sub-MS candidates suggest that extreme velocity ejections (>1000 km s-1) can accompany at most a small fraction of type Ia SNe, disfavouring a significant contribution of the D6-scenario to the origin of Ia SNe. The rate of HVS ejections following the hybrid WD reverse-detonation channel could be consistent with the identified HVSs. The numbers of lower-velocity HVS WDs could be consistent with type Iax SNe origin and/or contribution from dynamical encounters. We also searched for HVS WDs related to known SN remnants but identified only one such candidate ( https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2023MNRAS.518.6223I/abstract).

March 2025

26/03/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Strategies and tools to avoid Predatory Publishers
Uta Grothkopf (ESO)
12/03/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Looking for compact dual and lensed QSOs
Filippo Mannucci (INAF)

Abstract

I will describe an extended, ongoing observational effort aimed at discovering and studying the properties of a large sample of dual and strongly lensed QSOs at sub-arcsec separations. With these data, we will be able to address numerous scientific questions, including testing several previously untested predictions of galaxy/SMBH evolution models, developing more accurate predictions of massive BH merger rates and LISA GW event rates, and studying dark matter distribution in the central kpc of lensing galaxies. We select candidates using Gaia and Euclid data and follow up on targets with various space- and ground-based telescopes, including an ESO large program with VLT/MUSE, to obtain spatially resolved spectroscopy. This has produced, for the first time, a substantial sample of confirmed dual AGN beyond the local universe, and the most compact quadruply lensed QSO ever discovered.

05/03/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — The underrepresentation of women in computational astrophysics
Rebecca Nealon (Warwick University)

February 2025

26/02/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Ten years of Gaia, but less than three years of science
Henri Boffin (ESO)

Abstract

The Gaia mission has recently completed its last scientific observations. This is a good time to reflect on why this is a great mission, with one of the worst data access policy. I will provide a biased view on some of the revolutionary results it led to and provide a brief overview of what is still planned for the young and patient people in the audience.

19/02/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Mix, Cool, Repeat: Untangling the Turbulent & Magnetized CGM
Hitesh Kishore Das (MPA)

Abstract

Galaxies don’t just form stars—they continuously exchange gas with their surroundings. This circumgalactic medium (CGM) is a turbulent, magnetized mix of gas shaping how galaxies evolve. Observations reveal a multiphase CGM, but capturing this complexity in simulations is a major challenge due to small lengthscales involved. 

In this talk, I will explore:

- Why small-small effects in multiphase astrophysical gas are important?

- How turbulence & magnetic field shape CGM structure?

- How a new subgrid model can bring these small-scale effects to large-scale cosmological simulations?

 

By improving how we model the CGM, we can better interpret observational data and refine our understanding of galaxy evolution. Let's talk about how we can make that happen.

________________________________________________________________________________

 

The Informal Discussion is in-person only, and held in the ESO library.

 

At around 10:30, we will continue in the discussion at science coffee.

 

05/02/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Unmasking Hidden Bias: How Prestigious Fellowships in Astronomy and Astrophysics Navigate Selection Fairness
Paola Popesso (ESO Garching)

Abstract

Fellowship selection processes in academia are designed to reward scientific excellence, yet research suggests that bias—especially unconscious bias—can subtly influence evaluation outcomes, often disadvantaging underrepresented groups. In this informal discussion, we will first explore the impact of bias on selection processes, with a particular focus on hidden, unconscious biases that shape decision-making without evaluators even realizing it We will then examine how prestigious fellowship programs, including Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions (MSCA), the European Research Council (ERC), and other major astronomy and astrophysics fellowships, attempt to mitigate these biases. Using insights from peer-reviewed studies and official funding reports, we will analyze how different selection panels confront issues such as Halo bias, linguistic bias, and cognitive bias.

January 2025

15/01/25 (Wednesday)
10:00, Library (ESO HQ, Garching) | ESO Garching
Informal Discussion
Talk — Galaxies at z>=10, galaxy formation in ΛCDM, Ho tension(s) a Black Body Curve moment in Cosmology and/or Galaxy evolution?
Padelis Papadopoulos (AUTh/ESO)

Abstract

I will summarize 3 recent papers about galaxies at z>=10, and the Ho tension. I will then discuss, without offering solutions, whether such results place the standard Cosmological model en course towards the rocky shores of a funtamental(s) crisis.